Florida Campus Carry Law: Does It Go Far Enough


Teacher in front of a blackboard drawing a pistol from a holster.

To give a brief recap, the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting happened. I think we all know what happened there, the wildly-poor response of the Broward County Sheriff’s SRO, and later the entire top rank of that agency. As a result of the deaths and the follow up investigation, the State Legislature passed the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act, in March of 2018.


In over 20 years, there have been ZERO school shootings in Utah. Might it have something to do with the likelihood of being shot back at by a legally-armed adult?





This was the legislature attempting to make a positive effort to stop or at least reduce the carnage in future school shootings. The basis of this law allows non-instructors (unless current or previous military or law enforcement) with a carry permit to take an additional 132-hour training program to be allowed to carry on campus. This program would only be allowed if the local school board authorizes the program. Needless to say, the anti-gun anti-child safety crowd clutched their pearls so tightly they ended up with odd shaped diamonds.

The legislature has recently adjusted this law. The Coach Aaron Feis Guardian Program is now available to any classroom teacher regardless of prior work history. The program is named after the coach who chose to place his body between the shooter and his students, at the cost of his own life. The bitter pearl clingers with those misshapen diamonds are not clenching even tighter. Any teacher can carry on campus, if the school board authorizes the program at the local level.

Let me make sure we are all on the same page. If the Brevard County School Board authorizes the new program, teachers in Brevard County are now ALLOWED to invest 132 hours of their own time. At the end of the program, those who pass become authorized to be armed protection for their students. They are not paid to take the training. They are not mandated to take part in the program. They provide their own gun and they VOLUNTEER to do this.

If say, a Miami-Dade County School Board chooses to NOT authorize this program, their teachers have only one method of joining the The Coach Aaron Feis Guardian Program, moving to a School District that has authorized the program. However, the screeching is deafening. The rending of cloth over forcing all teachers to carry a gun, demanding that all children be forced to live in fear of armed teachers, and oh the propaganda against. Gabrielle Gifford’s group put out an analysis of on campus gun incidents.

First let’s realize the scope of this “analysis.” Over a four-year period, her group claims 67 gun-related incidents on campuses relating back to campus carry in the whole country. Just on its face, this is a small number of incidents considering 10 states have some version of a permissive Campus Carry law on the books, many others have much narrower options and most states have some variation of a School Resource Officer program in at least some schools. This means for literally hundreds of thousands of man hours, guns were on campuses during this “analysis” window, and they could only come up with 67 “mishandling” events.

Now let’s look a little closer at that list of 67 incidents. Of those, exactly one was committed by someone who would fall under the authority of the modified Coach Aaron Feis Guardian Program. That was an administrator in Texas who disarmed while on a trip to a school system that did not allow guns on campus. She forgot to rearm when she returned to the transport van and her firearm was found in the van the next day. Of course, this falls in the category of stupid, but not a negligent discharge or an injury to self or others.

Of the incidents counted, at least 10 were family or friends of students caught in violation of the no campus carry law. Roughly 30 were commissioned police officers who got complacent and improperly handled a gun or allowed others to do so. In multiple situations, the officer had a negligible discharge. Several of those situations resulted in injury to the officer or others. On two occasions, the officer in question was unable to stop a student from firing his or her holstered weapon. I don’t even know how that can happen in a proper police-issue holster. It is certainly impossible in any Safariland duty holster I have seen, and the same holds true for my girlfriend’s Blackhawk! duty holster.

This is not to say that police should not be on campus or that they should not be armed. It is to say that Florida’s 132 hours of firearms training is higher than any standard I have seen for a police academy graduate. It is also to say that no matter who is armed, they are people and people make mistakes. Of these, “squint real hard” to create 67 incidents over a four-year period, not a single death occurred. Now let’s compare that to the record of active shooters, oh wait…

I guess we could compare it to the state of Utah where, for all practical purposes, anyone with a carry permit is allowed to carry concealed while on campus. Guess how many injury incidents have been reported in 20 years of campus carry. ONE, and I am pretty sure every single instance would be thoroughly documented by the campus officials who hate guns and such freedom hating groups as “Moms Demand Attention Action”. In this case, a female teacher dropped her gun while removing it to use the bathroom. It fell and somehow “went off.” A fumble fingered grab attempt is the most likely cause, not by impact with the toilet as described. But, even in this case, the injury was caused by a shard of the shattered commode, not the bullet. The injury happened to the teacher and she very quickly became a former teacher.

There are two other school gun incidents listed for Utah in that 20-year period. In the first, two teenage gang members had an altercation that happened to be technically on school property. It happened in the middle of the night when one gang member shot the other.

The other was a student who brought a gun to school with the intention of committing suicide. He shot the ceiling, then waved it around before quickly surrendering the firearm with no one injured. Also be aware, this list holds such things as someone shooting a BB gun at a bus, as a school-related gun incident. If there were more gun related items, such silliness would not be needed to pad the list.

If anything, the Florida legislature has not gone far enough. With Utah as the example, anyone who has a carry permit should be allowed to carry on campus. No offense to truly professional School Resource Officers or workers at a school. There are a lot less of you than there are of us. When any parent comes on campus, they add a mystery to the mix. They are DIRECTLY motivated to protect their kid in a way no one else can be. In over 20 years, there have been ZERO school shootings in Utah. Might it have something to do with the likelihood of being shot back at by a legally-armed adult?

Are you in favor of armed teachers in the schools? What about armed parents? Share your answers in the comment section.

Original here

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s